When Tenancy Ends

What Happens at an Eviction Hearing?

A judge hears your proof of the ground and notice, then the tenant's defenses, and usually rules that day. Bring the lease, notice, proof of service, and rent ledger.

On this page
  1. What should you bring?
  2. How does the hearing run?
  3. What defenses do tenants raise, and how do you answer them?
  4. What if the tenant does not show up?
  5. What happens after you win or lose?

At an eviction hearing, a judge (or a jury, if one was requested) decides whether you had a legal ground to end the tenancy, whether you served the right notice correctly, and whether the tenant has a defense. You usually speak first, the tenant responds, and the judge often rules the same day. A tenant's absence does not always allow a default judgment; in California, you must still prove your case if an answer remains on file. Winning gives you a judgment for possession and any rent awarded; a sheriff or marshal still has to carry out the move-out.

What should you bring?

The judge decides from documents and witness testimony, so bring:

  • The lease and any renewals or written rule changes.
  • The termination notice and proof of service, such as the signed proof-of-service form or a declaration from the person who delivered it.
  • A rent ledger listing each charge, each payment, and the balance on the notice date. In a California nonpayment case, the notice may demand only rent, so separate late fees and utilities.
  • Photos, repair invoices, and inspection reports for damage or lease violations.
  • Texts, emails, and letters with the tenant about the problem.
  • Witnesses who saw the violation or served the notice. A witness who will not come voluntarily can be ordered to attend by subpoena.
  • A military status report if you expect to ask for a default.

California's court guide says to bring 2 copies of each piece of evidence, one for the judge and one for the tenant, and a written outline of what you will say. Keep a third set for yourself.

How does the hearing run?

California's court guide describes a typical eviction trial:

  1. Check in and wait. Plan on waiting up to 4 hours after your start time. If you leave before your case is heard, it may be dismissed.
  2. Settlement talks. The judge may send you and the tenant out to try to reach an agreement, sometimes with a mediator. Submit the signed agreement for court approval. In California, the court can approve an order without entering judgment or enter a stipulated judgment, a judgment on terms you both accepted. Obtaining judgment and a writ without another trial after a breach depends on what the approved agreement authorizes and requires you to follow its enforcement terms.
  3. Your case. As the landlord, you usually speak first. Show the lease, the ground, the notice, how and when it was served, and what is owed.
  4. The tenant's response. The tenant presents defenses and evidence. Do not interrupt; note points to answer and ask the judge for a chance to respond.
  5. The decision. The judge decides possession and any money you asked for in your complaint, often from the bench. The clerk gives or mails you the judgment.

What defenses do tenants raise, and how do you answer them?

Defense What the tenant argues What answers it
Defective notice or service The notice demanded the wrong amount, gave too few days, or was not delivered properly The notice itself, your day count, and proof of service
Habitability You failed to keep the unit livable, so rent was not fully owed Repair requests, work orders, invoices, and inspection reports
Retaliation You filed because the tenant complained to an inspector or used a legal right A dated record of the ground (missed rent, violation) that predates or is independent of the complaint
Rent paid or accepted The tenant paid, or you accepted rent after the notice Your ledger and bank records showing what was paid and when

The rules behind these defenses vary by state:

  • California: a tenant can claim the unit violated the implied warranty of habitability (the landlord's legal duty to keep a rental fit to live in). If that defense succeeds, the court may reduce the rent and order repairs. An eviction within 6 months after the tenant used certain rights, such as a code complaint, is presumed retaliatory, but only if the tenant's rent is current.
  • Florida: a habitability defense in a nonpayment case requires that the tenant gave you 7 days' written notice of the problem and of plans to withhold rent. A tenant raising any defense other than payment must, within 5 days after service, not counting weekends and holidays, deposit the rent into the court registry or file a motion asking the court to set the amount; doing neither waives those defenses. The tenant must also keep depositing rent into the court registry as it becomes due while the case is pending. Before dismissing for a defect in your notice or complaint, the court must give you a chance to correct it.
  • New York: if you started the case less than a year after the tenant's good-faith complaint, the law presumes retaliation, and you must prove a different reason for the case. This rule does not cover owner-occupied buildings with fewer than 4 units.

What if the tenant does not show up?

If the response deadline has passed and the tenant has not responded to the lawsuit, you may be able to ask for a default judgment, a ruling without the tenant defending the case. In California, if an answer remains on file and the tenant misses trial, ask the court to proceed without them and prove your case, provided the tenant received proper trial notice.

Before entering any default, the court requires you to file a sworn statement saying whether the tenant is in military service, under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (50 U.S.C. 3931). Knowingly filing a false statement is a crime punishable by a fine, up to 1 year in jail, or both.

To check status, use the Defense Manpower Data Center (DMDC) website, a Department of Defense database. Enter the tenant's last name and Social Security number, or date of birth if you do not have the number, and attach the report to your statement.

If the tenant is on active duty, the court must appoint a lawyer for the tenant before entering judgment, and it must pause the case for at least 90 days if that lawyer cannot reach the tenant or finds a defense the tenant must present. Separately, for a home renting for $10,542.60 a month or less in 2026, a servicemember or the servicemember's family can be evicted only by court order, and the court can delay the case for 90 days if military service materially affects the tenant's ability to pay.

What happens after you win or lose?

If you win, the judgment awards possession and can include back rent, rent for the days the tenant stayed after the tenancy ended, and court costs. Attorney's fees are recoverable in California only if the lease has a fee clause and you used a lawyer. The officer then gives the tenant a final notice before the lockout: 5 days in California and 14 days in New York, where the marshal or sheriff must serve written notice first. A money judgment does not collect itself; small claims and collecting a judgment covers wage garnishment and bank levies.

The tenant can still ask for more time.

  • In California, a losing tenant can ask the judge to delay the lockout, usually by days or weeks and conditioned on paying rent for that time, or to set aside a default for a good reason, such as improper service.
  • In New York, a judge can delay the eviction for up to 1 year if the tenant cannot find similar housing nearby or would suffer extreme hardship, but only while the tenant deposits rent with the court. In a lease-violation case, the tenant gets a 30-day stay to fix the violation.
  • Either side can appeal, on deadlines that vary by state.

If you lose, the tenant generally stays and you may owe the tenant's court costs. In a California nonpayment case, a tenant who wins a habitability defense can stay only if they pay the court-adjusted rent owed through trial by the court's deadline. That deadline is generally no more than 5 days after judgment, with extra time if the judgment is served by mail. If the tenant fails to pay on time, the court must award possession to you. You may have to make repairs, and the court limits rent to the unit's reasonable rental value until repairs are done. If the case failed on a notice or paperwork defect, you can usually serve a new, correct notice and file again.

For the full sequence from filing to lockout, see the steps for eviction proceedings. For the grounds and notices that decide many hearings, see the legal grounds for evicting a tenant. New York landlords can find the state's notice and court steps in New York's eviction process, and general ways to end a tenancy agreement covers alternatives to court.

Sources

  1. What to expect at an eviction trial (landlord) (Judicial Council of California, California Courts Self-Help Guide)
  2. Heidary v. Yadollahi (2002), default judgment versus an uncontested trial (California Court of Appeal, via Justia)
  3. California Code of Civil Procedure section 1174.2 (habitability defense and conditional possession) (California Legislature, via Justia)
  4. Opportunities for Settlement Before Trial in Unlawful Detainer Cases (form UD-155) (Judicial Council of California)
  5. A Guide to Residential Tenants' and Landlords' Rights and Responsibilities (2026 edition) (California Department of Real Estate)
  6. Florida Statutes section 83.60 (2026), Defenses to action for rent or possession (The Florida Senate)
  7. 50 U.S.C. 3931, Protection of servicemembers against default judgments (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
  8. Plaintiff's Guide to SCRA Compliance (Maryland Judiciary, District Court of Maryland)
  9. Notice of Publication of Housing Price Inflation Adjustment (2026 SCRA rent threshold, FR Doc. 2026-04689) (U.S. Department of Defense, Federal Register)
  10. New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law section 749 (warrant of eviction) (New York State Senate)
  11. New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law section 753 (stay of issuance of warrant) (New York State Senate)
  12. New York Real Property Law section 223-b (retaliation by landlord against tenant) (New York State Senate)

Legal Disclaimer: Tellus provides this content for informational purposes only. This is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and locality, and regulations may have changed since this article was published. Consult a qualified attorney for guidance specific to your situation.

Rules in your state

State law sets many of the limits and deadlines described above. These pages cite the statute for each state.

StateGuides
CaliforniaCalifornia Landlord Maintenance and Repair Obligations, California Eviction Process for Landlords, California Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
New YorkNew York Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, New York Rent Increase Rules for Landlords, New York Lease Agreements for Landlords, New York Eviction Process for Landlords, New York Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
TexasTexas Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, Texas Lease Agreements for Landlords, Texas Eviction Process for Landlords, Texas Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
FloridaFlorida Landlord Maintenance and Repair Obligations, Florida Eviction Process for Landlords, Florida Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
New JerseyNew Jersey Rent Increase Rules for Landlords, New Jersey Eviction Process for Landlords, New Jersey Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
IllinoisIllinois Landlord Maintenance and Repair Obligations, Illinois Eviction Process for Landlords
MassachusettsMassachusetts Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, Massachusetts Landlord Maintenance and Repair Obligations, Massachusetts Eviction Process for Landlords
PennsylvaniaPennsylvania Landlord Maintenance and Repair Obligations, Pennsylvania Eviction Process for Landlords
WashingtonWashington Eviction Process for Landlords
MarylandMaryland Landlord Maintenance and Repair Obligations, Maryland Eviction Process for Landlords

More in When Tenancy Ends

Free rental property management tools. Manage rentals from your phone.

There are no fees for opening or using Tellus. Available on iOS and Android.

Get the app