Investing

Should I Invest in an MBS Fund Instead of Individual Mortgage-Backed Securities?

A fund suits most small investors: low minimums, daily selling, and automatic reinvesting. Individual MBS suit larger buyers who want no annual fee.

On this page
  1. How do the two choices compare?
  2. What does owning individual MBS involve?
  3. What does owning an MBS fund involve?
  4. Which costs and risks are the same either way?
  5. Which situations favor each choice?

For most people buying in small amounts, an MBS mutual fund or exchange-traded fund (ETF) is the more practical choice: you can buy one share, sell on any trading day, spread your money across many mortgage pools, and let the fund reinvest the principal that comes back. Buying individual agency mortgage-backed securities (MBS) through a brokerage makes more sense when you have enough to buy several pools, want to avoid a yearly fund fee, and are willing to price trades and reinvest monthly principal yourself. Neither choice protects you from falling prices when interest rates rise.

How do the two choices compare?

Individual agency MBS MBS mutual fund or ETF
Smallest purchase $1,000 of original principal under Freddie Mac's rules; your brokerage may require more One ETF share, or the mutual fund's stated minimum
Ongoing cost None after purchase The fund's expense ratio, deducted from its net asset value (NAV)
Trading cost A dealer markup built into the price, which your trade confirmation does not have to show Any brokerage commission; ETFs also have a bid-ask spread (the gap between buying and selling prices), even on commission-free trades; mutual funds may charge sales loads (sales charges) or redemption fees
Diversification One pool per purchase Many pools in one share
Selling Through a dealer, at the price it offers Mutual fund: any business day at the next NAV. ETF: on an exchange while it is open
Monthly principal Paid to you in cash; you reinvest it Reinvested by the fund
End date Stated final payment date; the security can be paid off earlier as borrowers prepay None; the fund keeps buying new securities
Guarantee Ginnie Mae, Fannie Mae, or Freddie Mac guarantees principal and interest at face value Agency MBS holdings retain their guarantees; non-agency MBS holdings lack those guarantees. The share price has none

What a mortgage-backed security is explains the pools and guarantees behind both choices.

What does owning individual MBS involve?

Trade sizes. Freddie Mac requires its MBS to be held and transferred in amounts of at least $1,000 of original principal, in $1 steps. Brokerages decide which pools they offer and set their own minimums, so ask yours before you plan around a small amount.

Dealer markups. When a dealer sells you an MBS from its own inventory, its markup is built into the price. FINRA requires brokers to show the markup on retail confirmations for corporate and agency bonds, but that rule's definition of an agency bond excludes MBS. Ask the broker for the markup in dollars before you trade, and compare the price with another firm's.

Monthly principal. Each payment includes interest and part of your principal, because borrowers pay down their loans and some pay them off early. Small monthly principal payments are often below the $1,000 minimum, so they sit in cash until you have enough to buy more. If you skip reinvesting, your income shrinks each month.

Tracking the pool factor. The pool factor is the share of a pool's original principal still outstanding, as a decimal. Multiply it by your original amount to find what you still own. If you bought $20,000 of original principal and the factor drops to 0.80, you now hold $16,000 and earn interest only on that.

Paying above face value. The guarantee covers principal at face value, not any premium you paid above it. FINRA has told brokers that sell mortgage securities to explain this to customers who buy at a premium. Example: you pay $10,200 for $10,000 of principal (a price of 102). When $1,000 of that principal is repaid, you receive $1,000 for principal that cost you $1,020, so you lose $20. Faster prepayments, which come when rates fall and borrowers refinance, speed up that loss. Examples of mortgage-backed securities shows how prepayments affect each structure.

What does owning an MBS fund involve?

Expense ratio. The fund deducts its yearly fees and expenses from NAV, so you pay them indirectly. A fund with a 0.10% expense ratio costs $25 a year on a $25,000 balance; one charging 0.60% costs $150. The SEC notes that index funds, which track a benchmark, usually charge less than actively managed funds, whose results depend on the manager. Find the exact figure in the fee table of the fund's prospectus.

Diversification. One fund share gives you a slice of every pool the fund owns, so no single pool's prepayments drive your income.

Daily selling. A mutual fund buys back your shares at the next calculated NAV on any business day, minus any redemption fee. An ETF trades on an exchange at its market price whenever the market is open.

No maturity date. A fund keeps replacing bonds that pay down, so there is no date when you are scheduled to get your original amount back. Your result depends on the share price on the day you sell.

Which costs and risks are the same either way?

  • Interest rate risk. An individual MBS loses value when rates rise, just like a fund. The U.S. government does not guarantee the market price of a bond you sell before it is paid off. Holding an individual MBS lets you wait out a price drop, while a fund's price is what you get when you sell.
  • Prepayment and extension. Borrowers refinance when rates fall, returning principal when reinvesting it pays less. When rates rise, borrowers keep their loans longer, so your principal comes back more slowly. A fund spreads this across many pools but does not remove it.
  • Taxes. Under IRS Publication 550, interest from individual MBS and fund dividends from bond interest are generally taxed as ordinary income in a taxable account. Many ETFs distribute fewer capital gains than mutual funds because of how they trade portfolio securities. Earnings inside an IRA generally are not taxed when earned, so fewer capital-gains distributions offer no current-tax advantage there.

How MBS differ from other bonds explains why monthly principal and prepayments make MBS behave differently from Treasury and corporate bonds.

Which situations favor each choice?

Choose a fund or ETF if:

  • you are putting in less than enough to buy several pools at your brokerage's minimums;
  • you want monthly principal reinvested without placing new trades;
  • you may need to sell on short notice;
  • you do not want to compare dealer prices or track pool factors.

Choose individual MBS if:

  • you have enough to buy several pools and want to avoid paying an expense ratio every year;
  • you want to pick specific pools, such as Ginnie Mae pools backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government;
  • you want the monthly principal in cash, for example to cover expenses;
  • you can buy at or below face value, so prepayments do not cost you a premium.

If you want dividend income and accept borrowed money and larger price swings, mortgage REITs are a third route. How to invest in mortgages compares all four ways to earn mortgage interest, including private notes.

Sources

  1. UMBS and MBS Offering Circular (September 1, 2026): Final Payment Date and Guarantees, page 64 (Freddie Mac)
  2. Mortgage Products FAQ: minimum principal and transfer amounts, class factors (Freddie Mac)
  3. FINRA Rule 6710: Definitions (agency pass-through MBS, factor, agency debt security) (FINRA)
  4. FINRA Rule 2232: Customer Confirmations (mark-up disclosure for corporate and agency debt) (FINRA)
  5. Notice to Members 93-73: Members' Obligations to Customers When Selling Collateralized Mortgage Obligations (FINRA (NASD))
  6. Mortgage-Backed Securities and Collateralized Mortgage Obligations (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov)
  7. Bond Funds and Income Funds (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov)
  8. Mutual Funds (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov)
  9. Updated Investor Bulletin: Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov)
  10. Mutual Fund and ETF Fees and Expenses: Investor Bulletin (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov)
  11. Fidelity Mortgage Securities Fund: Portfolio Manager Q&A, February 28, 2026 (Investment Approach) (Fidelity Investments)
  12. Publication 550 (2025), Investment Income and Expenses: Interest, Dividends, and IRAs (Internal Revenue Service)

Financial Disclaimer: Tellus provides this content for informational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Financial returns and mortgage terms vary based on individual circumstances and market conditions. Consult a qualified financial advisor before making financial or borrowing decisions.

More in Investing

Savings tools and property management powered by real estate.

There are no fees for opening or using Tellus. Available on iOS and Android.

Get the app