What Can You Do When a Tenant Breaks the Lease Early?
The tenant usually owes rent until you re-rent or the lease ends, and most states require you to try to re-rent. Military orders and abuse can end liability.
When a tenant moves out before the lease ends without a legal reason, they generally owe rent until you re-rent the unit or the lease ends, whichever comes first, plus your reasonable costs of finding a new tenant. In California, New York, and Texas, you must make a reasonable effort to re-rent and cannot collect rent you could have avoided losing; Florida lets you choose. A tenant with qualifying military orders, a tenant who is a victim of domestic violence, or a tenant whose unit became unlivable can often leave owing little or nothing more.
What does the tenant owe when they leave early?
California's statute lays out the standard pieces of the claim. After a tenant abandons the unit, you can recover:
- Rent unpaid at move-out, such as a month they skipped before leaving.
- Rent lost while the unit sits empty, minus any loss the tenant shows you could reasonably have avoided.
- Other losses the move-out caused, such as advertising and screening costs, and a lower rent from the replacement tenant for the rest of the original term.
Once a new tenant starts paying, the old tenant owes at most the difference if the new rent is lower, and in New York not even that.
Do you have to try to re-rent the unit?
In California, New York, and Texas, yes, and Florida gives you a choice. This is called the duty to mitigate: you must take reasonable steps to reduce your loss. The states differ in who must prove what and whether a lease can change the rule.
| State | Duty to re-rent | Burden and waiver |
|---|---|---|
| California | Your recovery is reduced by any rent loss the tenant proves you could have reasonably avoided | The tenant must prove the loss was avoidable |
| New York | You must try in good faith to re-rent at fair market value or the old rent, whichever is lower | You must prove your damages; a lease clause waiving the duty is void |
| Texas | You must mitigate if the tenant abandons the unit in violation of the lease | A lease clause waiving the duty is void |
| Florida | You choose: end the lease and take the unit back for yourself (the tenant owes no more rent), re-rent for the tenant's account in good faith, or leave the unit empty and collect rent as it comes due | The fee option below needs a separate signed addendum |
In New York, once you re-rent at that rate, the new lease cuts off the old tenant's liability for later rent.
Reasonable effort means treating the unit like any other vacancy:
- List it within days of learning the tenant has left, at a market rent.
- Use your normal screening standards, not stricter ones.
- Show the unit and answer inquiries promptly.
- Keep copies of every listing, with dates, and a log of showings and applications.
Those records are your evidence if the tenant says you let the unit sit. A tenant who offers a qualified replacement also gives you a fast way to re-rent; see whether your tenant can find a replacement.
When can a tenant leave without owing more?
Military orders. Under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act, a tenant can end a residential lease if they signed it and then entered military service, or signed it while in service and then received permanent change of station orders or orders to deploy for 90 days or more. The tenant gives written notice with a copy of the orders. For a lease with monthly rent, the lease ends 30 days after the next rent due date following the notice. You may not charge an early termination fee, you must refund prepaid rent for any period after that date within 30 days, and you may not hold the security deposit to cover rent after termination. Texas has a parallel state rule.
Domestic violence and related crimes. Many states let victims end a lease early:
- California: A tenant who was a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, stalking, human trafficking, elder abuse, or certain violent crimes, or whose household member was, can give written notice with a protective order, police report, or qualified third-party statement within 180 days of the order, report, or act. The tenant owes rent for no more than 14 days after the notice. You cannot keep the deposit because of the termination. Under Civil Code section 1946.7(g), the release also covers family members living in the same unit as the terminating tenant; other co-tenants stay bound by the lease.
- Texas: A tenant with a qualifying protective order or documentation from a health care provider, mental health provider, or advocate can end the lease by giving you the required documentation, giving 30 days' written notice, and moving out, with no rent due after termination. If the perpetrator is a co-tenant or occupant, the tenant can terminate without the 30-day notice period after providing documentation that qualifies under Texas Property Code section 92.016(c-1) and moving out. If your lease lacks the statement "Tenants may have special statutory rights to terminate the lease early in certain situations involving family violence or a military deployment or transfer," the tenant is also released from rent already past due.
Unlivable conditions. If the tenant left because you did not fix a serious problem after notice, such as no heat or a major leak, the tenant may argue the lease ended through your breach. See when a tenant can move out over bad conditions.
Can you charge an early termination fee or agree to a buyout?
A fee written into the lease is limited by state law:
- Florida allows a fee or liquidated damages of up to 2 months' rent only if the tenant chose that option at signing in a separate addendum. The tenant can be required to give no more than 60 days' notice, and you can also collect rent through the month you retake the unit plus charges for damage.
- California voids a liquidated damages clause in a residential lease unless actual damages would be impracticable or extremely difficult to calculate. Lost rent usually is not hard to calculate, so a flat fee clause is risky.
A buyout agreement made when the tenant asks to leave is a different tool. You agree in writing that the tenant pays a set amount by a set move-out date, and in return you release the tenant from all rent after that date. Put the amount, the date, how the deposit will be handled, and the release in one signed document. Do not ask a tenant covered by the military or domestic violence rules to pay one.
How do you calculate and collect the balance?
Here is a worked example. The lease runs January 1 to December 31 at $2,000 a month. The tenant pays through June and moves out June 30. You list the unit on July 2, and a new tenant starts September 1 at $2,000.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Lost rent, July and August (2 x $2,000) | $4,000 |
| Listing and screening costs | $150 |
| Total owed | $4,150 |
| Less security deposit (no damage deductions) | -$2,000 |
| Balance due from the tenant | $2,150 |
The tenant owes nothing for September through December, because the new tenant's rent covers those months.
To collect:
- Send the deposit accounting on time. Itemize every deduction within your state's deadline, even when the deposit does not cover the balance. See what to watch when returning a security deposit.
- Send a demand letter with the itemized balance, your re-renting records, and a payment deadline.
- File in small claims court if the tenant does not pay and your claim is within your jurisdiction's limit for an individual or business landlord. To claim a larger amount, use the appropriate civil court procedure. Bring the lease, the listings, and the new lease.
- Pursue co-tenants. If the lease had more than one tenant, the ones who signed may share the balance. See signing a lease with more than one person.
For the lease terms that set rent, length, and early termination rules from the start, see what a lease agreement covers.
Sources
- 50 U.S.C. section 3955, Termination of residential or motor vehicle leases (Servicemembers Civil Relief Act) (Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute)
- Cal. Civil Code section 1951.2, Lessor's damages on abandonment (California.Public.Law (text of the California Codes))
- Cal. Civil Code section 1671, Liquidated damages (California.Public.Law (text of the California Codes))
- Cal. Civil Code section 1946.7, Termination by victims of abuse or violent crime (California.Public.Law (text of the California Codes))
- 2026 Real Estate Law, Civil Code section 1946.7(g)-(h), Household members and co-tenants (California Department of Real Estate)
- New York Real Property Law section 227-E, Duty to mitigate damages (New York State Senate)
- Tex. Prop. Code section 91.006, Landlord's duty to mitigate damages (Texas Legislature)
- Tex. Prop. Code section 92.016, Right to vacate and avoid liability following family violence (Texas Legislature)
- Fla. Stat. section 83.595, Choice of remedies upon breach or early termination by tenant (The Florida Senate)
- Deciding between small claims and limited civil (California Courts)
Legal Disclaimer: Tellus provides this content for informational purposes only. This is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and locality, and regulations may have changed since this article was published. Consult a qualified attorney for guidance specific to your situation.
Rules in your state
State law sets many of the limits and deadlines described above. These pages cite the statute for each state.
More in Lease
Related reading
Free rental property management tools. Manage rentals from your phone.
There are no fees for opening or using Tellus. Available on iOS and Android.