What Caused the 2008 Mortgage Crisis?
Risky subprime and adjustable-rate loans, private mortgage securities rated AAA, and heavy borrowing by lenders turned the 2006 home price peak into a 2008 crash.
The 2008 mortgage crisis was caused by a housing boom financed with loans many borrowers could not repay, which Wall Street packaged into securities that rating agencies marked as safe and that heavily indebted financial firms held in bulk. When home prices peaked in 2006 and began to fall, defaults on subprime and adjustable-rate loans rose, those securities lost value, and firms that had borrowed as much as $40 for every $1 of their own capital failed or needed government rescues in 2008. The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission (FCIC), the panel Congress created to investigate, concluded in January 2011 that the crisis was avoidable.
What happened in 2007 and 2008?
National home prices, measured by the S&P Cotality Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index, peaked in July 2006. In April 2007, New Century Financial, one of the largest subprime lenders, filed for bankruptcy. On August 9, 2007, the French bank BNP Paribas froze three investment funds because it could not value their U.S. mortgage securities, and short-term lending between banks tightened. The U.S. economy entered a recession in December 2007.
The failures came in 2008:
- March: Bear Stearns, a Wall Street investment bank, was sold to JPMorgan Chase with Federal Reserve financing.
- July: regulators closed IndyMac Bank, and Congress passed the Housing and Economic Recovery Act, which created a new regulator for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
- September: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were placed in government conservatorship (control by the Federal Housing Finance Agency), Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy, and the Fed lent up to $85 billion to the insurer AIG.
- October: Congress created the $700 billion Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP), which Treasury used to buy shares in banks.
The recession lasted until June 2009. Inflation-adjusted output fell about 4.0% from the second quarter of 2008 to the second quarter of 2009, and unemployment rose from under 5% to 10%, the deepest recession since World War II. Home prices kept falling until February 2012, about 27% below the 2006 peak. When the FCIC reported in 2011, about 4 million families had lost homes to foreclosure and households had lost nearly $11 trillion in wealth. The dated timeline of the crisis lists each event, and the effects of the 2008 crisis covers the damage to homeowners and jobs.
What chain of causes led to the crisis?
No single cause explains the crisis. The FCIC record traces four links in the chain.
1. Cheap credit and rising prices
The Federal Reserve held its benchmark short-term rate near 1% from mid-2003 to mid-2004, and, according to Ben Bernanke's 2005 explanation, foreign savings flowing into U.S. bonds kept long-term mortgage rates low. Home prices rose more than 100% from 1998 to 2006, and mortgage debt grew from 61% to 97% of the economy's annual output. Builders started homes at an annual pace of 2.27 million in January 2006, more than a 30-year high. The FCIC found that low rates and plentiful capital were preconditions for a credit bubble but did not have to produce a crisis; how the money was lent did.
2. Loosened underwriting: subprime and adjustable-rate lending
Lenders relaxed the checks on whether a borrower could repay. Subprime mortgages, loans to borrowers with weak credit, grew from 8% of new mortgages in 2003 to 20% in 2005. In 2006, lenders made $600 billion of subprime loans, 23.5% of all mortgage lending. About 70% of subprime borrowers used hybrid adjustable-rate mortgages such as the 2/28, which carried a low "teaser" rate for 2 years and then adjusted periodically, and lenders often qualified borrowers at the teaser rate. Nearly one-quarter of all mortgages made in the first half of 2005 were interest-only, and many loans required little or no proof of income. How subprime mortgages worked explains these loan features in detail.
3. Private-label securitization and inflated ratings
Most subprime loans were not held by the lender. They were sold to Wall Street firms, pooled, and turned into private-label mortgage-backed securities, meaning bonds issued without a Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, or Ginnie Mae guarantee. These securities supplied most of the money for subprime lending. Firms then repackaged the riskier pieces into collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), bonds backed by other mortgage bonds.
Investors bought these bonds because rating agencies graded much of them AAA, the top grade. From 2000 to 2007, Moody's rated nearly 45,000 mortgage-related securities AAA, and 83% of the mortgage securities it rated AAA in 2006 were later downgraded. The FCIC found that no one in the chain kept enough of the risk: each party expected to pass it to the next buyer, so few checked whether the loans would be repaid.
4. High leverage at lenders and Wall Street firms
Leverage means using borrowed money to buy assets. In 2007, the five major investment banks had leverage ratios as high as 40 to 1, so a drop of less than 3% in the value of their assets could wipe out their capital. Much of that borrowing was overnight: at the end of 2007, Bear Stearns had $11.8 billion of equity and was borrowing as much as $70 billion overnight. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac had a combined leverage ratio of 75 to 1 counting the loans they guaranteed. Households borrowed heavily too: mortgage debt per household rose more than 63% from 2001 to 2007, from $91,500 to $149,500, while wages were flat.
Why did home prices fall after the 2006 peak?
Prices fell because the supply of easy credit that had pushed them up stopped, and the loans made at the top began to fail:
- Rates rose. The Fed raised its benchmark rate from 1% in mid-2004 to 5.25% by mid-2006. Payments on adjustable-rate loans rose as they reset, and a 2/28 payment could double or triple once the teaser period ended.
- Refinancing stopped working. Many subprime borrowers planned to refinance before the reset, which worked only while their home's value kept rising. Once prices flattened, they could neither refinance nor sell for enough to pay off the loan.
- Defaults shut off subprime funding. As delinquencies rose in 2007, investors stopped buying subprime securities, lenders stopped making the riskiest loans, and fewer buyers could get financing.
- Foreclosures added supply. Lenders sold repossessed homes into a weak market, which pushed prices lower and put more owners underwater, meaning they owed more than the home was worth. By 2010, nearly one-quarter of mortgage borrowers were underwater.
The sharpest boom-and-bust cycles were in California, Nevada, Arizona, and Florida. In Nevada, nearly 70% of mortgage borrowers were underwater in 2010.
Who was responsible?
The FCIC majority assigned responsibility across the system:
| Party | What the FCIC found |
|---|---|
| Lenders and mortgage brokers | Made loans with "willful disregard" for the borrower's ability to pay; some brokers were paid more by lenders for placing borrowers in higher-cost loans |
| Securitizers (Wall Street firms) | Sampled the loans they bought, found many failed underwriting standards, and sold the securities anyway |
| Credit rating agencies | Called "essential cogs" of the crisis; mortgage bonds could not have been sold in volume without their ratings |
| Regulators | The Federal Reserve did not set mortgage lending standards it had the power to set; the SEC did not require more capital at investment banks |
| Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac | Contributed but were not a primary cause; they followed Wall Street into riskier loans |
The majority found that the Community Reinvestment Act, a 1977 law requiring banks to lend in the areas where they take deposits, was not a significant factor: only 6% of high-cost loans had any connection to it.
Four of the 10 commissioners dissented. Keith Hennessey, Douglas Holtz-Eakin, and Bill Thomas listed 10 causes, starting with a global credit bubble, and wrote that many borrowers did not take responsibility for understanding their loan terms. Peter Wallison argued that federal housing policy, including affordable housing goals set for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, was the essential cause. Did Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac cause the crisis weighs that evidence.
How did housing losses become the 2008 failures and rescues?
The FCIC found that mortgage losses were concentrated in a set of large, interconnected firms that held mortgage securities with borrowed money, much of it renewed every night. When the value of those securities fell, lenders refused to renew the loans, and a firm could run out of cash within days. Bear Stearns faced that kind of run in March 2008.
The government's response varied by firm. It arranged a sale of Bear Stearns, put Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac into conservatorship on September 6, let Lehman Brothers fail on September 15, and rescued AIG the next day. AIG had sold insurance-like contracts called credit default swaps that promised to cover losses on mortgage securities, and it could not pay; the government ultimately committed more than $180 billion to it. The FCIC concluded that this inconsistent handling added to the panic.
After Lehman failed, a large money market fund fell below $1 per share, and investors pulled $349 billion from prime money market funds (funds that buy short-term debt from banks and other companies) within a week. Credit markets froze. Treasury used TARP to buy bank shares, and the Fed cut its benchmark rate to a range of 0% to 0.25% on December 16, 2008.
What changed after the crisis?
The Dodd-Frank Act, signed July 21, 2010, gave regulators new powers over large financial firms and required new mortgage lending rules. Since January 10, 2014, federal ability-to-repay rules require a lender to verify your income and assets with records such as pay stubs and tax returns, and to judge whether you can afford the payment at the loan's full adjusted rate, not just its starting rate. Lenders can no longer qualify a borrower at a teaser rate the way they did with many 2/28 loans. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac remain in conservatorship as of October 2026.
How the United States recovered from the 2008 crisis covers the relief programs and the rebound. If you have or are shopping for an adjustable-rate loan, protecting yourself from a future mortgage crisis lists the steps to take.
Sources
- The Financial Crisis Inquiry Report (January 2011) (Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, via U.S. Government Publishing Office)
- The Great Recession and Its Aftermath (Federal Reserve History)
- Real Gross Domestic Product (GDPC1) (U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, via Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED))
- Subprime Mortgage Crisis, 2007-2010 (Federal Reserve History)
- S&P Cotality Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index (CSUSHPINSA) (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED))
- Federal Funds Effective Rate (FEDFUNDS) (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED))
- New Privately-Owned Housing Units Started: Total Units (HOUST) (U.S. Census Bureau and U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, via Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED))
- The Financial Crisis: A Timeline of Events and Policy Actions (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRASER))
- Conservatorship (Federal Housing Finance Agency)
- 12 CFR 1026.43, Minimum standards for transactions secured by a dwelling (ability to repay) (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations)
- Public Law 111-203, Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (U.S. Government Publishing Office)
- Ability-to-Repay Rule: Protecting Homebuyers from Debt Traps (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)
Financial Disclaimer: Tellus provides this content for informational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Financial returns and mortgage terms vary based on individual circumstances and market conditions. Consult a qualified financial advisor before making financial or borrowing decisions.
More in 2008 Mortgage Crisis
Related reading
Savings tools and property management powered by real estate.
There are no fees for opening or using Tellus. Available on iOS and Android.