How Do Mortgage Servicers Make Money?
Servicers earn a yearly fee, often 0.25% of your loan balance, taken from your interest, plus float, late fees, and other charges, and they can sell servicing rights.
Mortgage servicers earn most of their money from a servicing fee: a yearly percentage of your unpaid loan balance that the servicer keeps out of the interest you pay each month. On fixed-rate loans that Fannie Mae buys, that fee is at least 0.25% and at most 0.50% of the balance a year. Servicers also earn interest on payments and escrow money they hold before passing it on, keep late fees and some other charges, and can sell the right to service your loan. You pay the servicing fee indirectly through your interest rate; late fees and other charges you pay directly, and your loan documents, the loan owner's rules, and federal servicing rules limit them.
How does the servicing fee work?
The servicer collects your full payment, keeps its fee from the interest portion, and sends the rest of the principal and interest to whoever owns the loan, such as Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, or investors in mortgage-backed securities. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide says that unless the servicing contract provides otherwise, lenders deduct their servicing fee from the borrower's interest payment each month. The fee does not appear as a separate line on your statement, and your payment is the same whatever the fee is.
Fannie Mae's servicing guide sets a fee of 0.25% to 0.50% a year for most fixed-rate loans in its securities, and a 0.25% minimum for most adjustable-rate loans. Because the fee is a percentage of the balance, it shrinks as you pay the loan down.
Worked example. A $300,000, 30-year fixed-rate loan at 6.5% has a principal and interest payment of $1,896.20. With a 0.25% servicing fee:
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Interest in the first month ($300,000 x 6.5% / 12) | $1,625.00 |
| Servicing fee in the first month ($300,000 x 0.25% / 12) | $62.50 |
| Interest passed to the loan's owner | $1,562.50 |
| Servicing fee for the first year (about $300,000 x 0.25%) | about $750 |
| Servicing fee a year, after 10 years (balance about $254,328) | about $636 |
The Financial Stability Oversight Council (FSOC), a panel of federal financial regulators, reported that the servicing fee is well above the average cost to service a loan that is paid on time ($160 per loan in the first half of 2022) but below the average cost for a delinquent loan ($1,994). The fee stays the same when a borrower falls behind, so a servicer earns less, or loses money, as more of its loans go delinquent.
What is float, and who keeps it?
Float is the interest a servicer earns on money it holds for a short time. Your monthly payment sits in a custodial account until the servicer sends principal and interest to the owner, and your escrow money sits there until the servicer pays your tax bill and insurance premium. When you pay off or refinance, FSOC notes, the payoff money stays with the servicer for a few weeks before it goes to the investor.
Fannie Mae's guide allows the servicer to withdraw interest earned on an interest-bearing account that holds principal and interest. For the tax and insurance account, it lists paying interest to the borrower as a permitted use, which applies where the law requires interest on escrow. Where no such requirement applies, you generally earn no interest on your escrow balance.
Which charges do you pay directly, and what limits them?
Fannie Mae lets servicers keep late charges and fees for certain servicing activities, on top of the servicing fee. These are the charges you see:
| Charge | Main limits |
|---|---|
| Late fee | Conventional loans sold to Fannie Mae: up to 5% of the principal and interest payment, for a payment not received within 15 days of the due date. FHA loans with a case number assigned on or after March 14, 2016: up to 4% of the overdue principal and interest, for a payment received more than 15 days after the due date, and only after the servicer gives you advance written notice of the charge. Older FHA loans can base it on the full payment including escrow if the note allows. Either way, state law must also allow the fee. |
| Late fee on a late fee | Not allowed. If your only shortfall is an unpaid earlier late fee and the current payment arrives on time, the servicer cannot charge another late fee. |
| Force-placed insurance | Insurance the servicer buys if your homeowners policy lapses. It needs a reasonable basis, written notices at least 45 days and again at least 15 days before charging you, charges that are bona fide and reasonable, and a refund for any overlap within 15 days after you show proof of coverage. |
| Other fees | Any fee must have a reasonable basis. A fee without one, such as a late fee on a payment that was not late, counts as an error you can dispute in writing at no cost. |
On the example loan, a 5% late fee would be $94.81 ($1,896.20 x 5%), and a 4% FHA late fee would be $75.85 ($1,896.20 x 4%). Federal rules also require the servicer to credit a regular payment as of the day it receives it, so a slow-posted payment cannot trigger a late fee; the prompt payment crediting rule explains when the clock starts. For the force-placed insurance notices and how to get the charge removed, see whether servicers can charge you for force-placed insurance.
What are servicing rights worth?
The right to collect the servicing fee on a loan is an asset called a mortgage servicing right (MSR). Servicers carry MSRs as an asset on their balance sheets, valued with models that estimate the net revenue they expect from servicing the loans, and they can sell them to another servicer or borrow against them. That is one reason your servicer can change while your lender and loan terms stay the same; the difference between a servicer and a mortgage holder explains who owns what.
MSR values move with interest rates. When rates rise, fewer borrowers refinance, so servicers expect to collect the fee for longer and MSRs gain value. When rates fall and borrowers refinance, the loans pay off early, the fee stops, and MSR values drop. FSOC notes that some lenders keep servicing in-house partly because regular contact with borrowers makes those borrowers more likely to refinance with the same company.
Servicing also has costs that the fee has to cover. When a borrower misses a payment, the servicer may have to advance the missed principal and interest to investors, plus taxes and insurance. For loans in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac securities, required principal and interest advances are limited to 120 consecutive days, and advances for taxes, insurance, and foreclosure costs are generally reimbursed quickly. Servicers of Ginnie Mae pools, which hold FHA, VA, and USDA loans, keep advancing until the delinquency is resolved, which can take years. What Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are covers their role, and what loan servicing is covers what your servicer must do in return for its fee.
Sources
- Selling Guide C2-1.1-05: Servicing Fees (Fannie Mae)
- Servicing Guide Exhibit F-2-08: Servicing Fees for MBS Mortgage Loans (Fannie Mae)
- Servicing Guide A2-3-01: Servicer Compensation (Fannie Mae)
- Servicing Guide F-1-03: Establishing and Implementing Custodial Accounts (Fannie Mae)
- Selling Guide B8-3-02: Special Note Provisions and Language Requirements (late charges) (Fannie Mae)
- FHA Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1, III.A.2.c: Late Charges (U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development)
- Report on Nonbank Mortgage Servicing 2024 (Financial Stability Oversight Council)
- Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.36: Prohibited acts or practices (payment crediting and late fees) (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)
- Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.35: Error resolution procedures (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)
- Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.37: Force-placed insurance (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)
Financial Disclaimer: Tellus provides this content for informational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Financial returns and mortgage terms vary based on individual circumstances and market conditions. Consult a qualified financial advisor before making financial or borrowing decisions.
More in Loan Servicing
Related reading
Savings tools and property management powered by real estate.
There are no fees for opening or using Tellus. Available on iOS and Android.