What Do You Do When a Neighbor Is a Nuisance?
Log the problem, ask the neighbor in writing, then use code enforcement, the HOA, mediation, or court. If the neighbor is your own tenant, enforce the lease.
A neighbor is a legal nuisance when their conduct substantially and unreasonably interferes with the use or enjoyment of your rental, usually over and over, not once. If the neighbor does not rent from you, work up a written record, ask them in writing to stop, then use code enforcement or the HOA, mediation, and finally small claims or a nuisance lawsuit. If the neighbor is another of your tenants, you control the fix through the lease, and ignoring complaints puts you at risk with the tenant who complained.
What legally counts as a nuisance?
Courts judge unreasonableness by asking whether an average person would find the activity annoying, how the harm compares with the usefulness of the activity, and who was there first. A complaint based on one person's unusual sensitivity does not qualify. In practice that means:
- Usually a nuisance: a dog that barks for hours every night, a neighbor who runs a loud generator or holds late parties several nights a week, smoke or odors that enter your unit daily, water from a neighbor's yard that floods your foundation.
- Usually not: a single party, normal daytime noise like footsteps or children playing, a neighbor's house color or yard style you dislike.
The remedies are money damages and, when money will not fix it, an injunction, which is a court order to stop.
What are the most common neighbor disputes?
Each type of dispute has its own first stop, which is often faster than a lawsuit.
| Dispute | Typical problem | First place to take it |
|---|---|---|
| Noise | Late-night parties, music, barking, equipment | The neighbor, then the city's noise ordinance (police non-emergency line or 311) |
| Pets | Barking, waste, a loose or aggressive dog | The neighbor, then animal control |
| Trees and boundaries | Overhanging branches, roots, fences, encroachments | The neighbor in writing, with a survey if the line is unclear |
| Parking | Blocked driveways, cars in assigned spaces | Parking enforcement or towing rules, or the HOA on private streets |
| Trash and property condition | Overflowing bins, junk, overgrown yards, pests | City code enforcement |
Trees deserve caution. Do not let your tenant or a contractor cut a neighbor's tree without the neighbor's written consent. In California, wrongfully injuring or removing trees on someone else's land can result in 2 times the actual damage, even for an innocent mistake; courts may increase the award to 3 times the actual damage for willful and malicious conduct (Cal. Civ. Code section 3346).
If the rental is in an HOA or condo, the association enforces its own rules on noise, pets, parking, and trash against the neighbor. File a written complaint with the manager or board and cite the rule.
What steps do you take when the neighbor is not your tenant?
You have no lease to enforce against an outside neighbor, so the remedies run against the neighbor directly. Either you or your tenant can act. California, for example, lets any person whose property is harmed or whose personal enjoyment is lessened by a nuisance sue to stop it and recover damages.
- Build a record. Ask your tenant to keep a dated log of each incident with times, what happened, and photos, video, or audio. Illinois Legal Aid recommends a diary because the paper trail supports every later step.
- Talk, then write. Have a calm conversation first. If it continues, send a short dated letter that names the problem, the dates, and what you are asking for, and keep a copy.
- File a complaint with the right office. Use the city's code enforcement office, police non-emergency line, animal control, or the HOA from the table above. A citation or violation notice also becomes evidence.
- Try mediation. Many courts and counties run community mediation programs. For example, Bexar County, Texas, provides mediation to county residents at no charge. Both sides must agree to take part.
- Go to court. For money, such as the cost of repairing water damage, use small claims. In California, individuals can sue for up to $12,500 there and businesses for up to $6,250. To make the neighbor stop, you generally need a nuisance lawsuit in regular civil court asking for an injunction, and a lawyer is worth consulting first.
Answer your own tenant's complaint in writing and say which of these steps you are taking. If the tenant later claims you ignored the problem, that letter is your record.
Are you liable if the nuisance is another of your tenants?
You can be. Every lease carries an implied right of quiet enjoyment, and because you can enforce your other tenants' leases, the complaining tenant will expect you to act. A landlord who is told about a serious, ongoing disturbance by another tenant and does nothing can face a lawsuit for damages, or a tenant who moves out and claims the lease was broken. See the landlord's duty to provide quiet enjoyment for how that claim works.
The steps in the next section apply. Start with the first credible complaint, and tell the complaining tenant in writing what you are doing.
What do you do when your own tenant is the nuisance?
Treat a neighbor's complaint about your tenant as a lease issue:
- Check the facts. Ask the neighbor for dates and any recordings, and ask your tenant for their side.
- Point to the lease. A clause on quiet hours, guests, pets, or parking gives you a specific rule to enforce. State law may already supply one. Florida, for example, requires tenants to make sure they and their guests do not unreasonably disturb neighbors or breach the peace (Fla. Stat. section 83.52(7)).
- Send a written warning. Name the rule, the incidents, and what happens next.
- Use the state's notice if it continues. In Florida, a repeated or continued unreasonable disturbance supports a 7-day notice to vacate with no chance to cure. In California, a nuisance that cannot be corrected can support a 3-day notice to quit without a chance to fix it. If the tenancy is covered by the Tenant Protection Act and the violation can be corrected, such as noise, first serve a formal 3-day notice to fix the violation or move out, excluding weekends and court holidays. Only if the tenant fails to fix it within that period may you then serve a 3-day notice to quit without a chance to fix it (Cal. Civ. Code section 1946.2(c)). If the tenant does not leave, the next step is an eviction case, not a lockout.
If the complaints involve drug sales, violence, or other crimes, see how to deal with a tenant's illegal activity.
In an HOA, your tenant's violations can cost you. Florida homeowners' associations, for example, can fine a member's tenant up to $100 per violation, and up to $1,000 in total for a continuing violation, unless the governing documents allow more. Before imposing a fine, the board must give the owner and affected tenant at least 14 days' written notice of the right to a hearing, and the hearing committee must approve the fine by majority vote. No fine may be imposed if the violation is corrected before the hearing or as specified in the required notices issued before or after the hearing. Read your association's rules and pass them to your tenant as part of the lease.
Tellus tip
Add a clause to your lease that makes the HOA rules part of the lease and lets you charge the tenant for any HOA fine their conduct causes, then attach the current rules at signing.
For the other clauses that make these steps enforceable, see what a lease agreement should cover.
Sources
- Nuisance (Wex legal encyclopedia) (Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute)
- Cal. Code of Civil Procedure section 731, Actions to abate a nuisance (California.Public.Law (text of the California Codes))
- Cal. Code of Civil Procedure section 1161, Unlawful detainer (California.Public.Law (text of the California Codes))
- Cal. Civil Code section 1946.2, Just cause and opportunity to cure (California.Public.Law (text of the California Codes))
- Cal. Civil Code section 3346, Damages for injury to trees (California.Public.Law (text of the California Codes))
- Salazar v. Matejcek (2016), Discretionary treble damages for injury to trees (California Court of Appeal (via Justia))
- Fla. Stat. section 83.52, Tenant's obligation to maintain dwelling unit (The Florida Senate)
- Fla. Stat. section 83.56, Termination of rental agreement (The Florida Senate)
- Fla. Stat. section 720.305, Obligations of members; remedies at law or in equity; levy of fines (The Florida Senate)
- Small claims in California (Judicial Branch of California)
- Can I do anything about my noisy neighbors? (Illinois Legal Aid Online)
- Dispute Resolution Center, About and Mission (Bexar County, Texas)
Legal Disclaimer: Tellus provides this content for informational purposes only. This is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and locality, and regulations may have changed since this article was published. Consult a qualified attorney for guidance specific to your situation.
Rules in your state
State law sets many of the limits and deadlines described above. These pages cite the statute for each state.
More in Lease
Related reading
Free rental property management tools. Manage rentals from your phone.
There are no fees for opening or using Tellus. Available on iOS and Android.