Does Liability Coverage Have a Maximum Amount?
Yes. Every liability policy caps what it pays per occurrence, and commercial policies add a yearly aggregate. You owe anything above the limit, plus uninsurable damages.
Yes. Every liability policy has a maximum, shown on the declarations page as a limit per occurrence (one accident or event), and commercial general liability policies add an annual aggregate limit for claims covered by each policy year. The standard homeowners and commercial forms pay legal defense costs on top of the limit, but the insurer stops defending once it has paid the full limit in a settlement or judgment. You owe anything above the limit, and no limit covers intentional harm or, in states such as California and New York, punitive damages.
How per-occurrence and aggregate limits work
A per-occurrence limit is the most the policy pays for all injuries and damage from one event, no matter how many people are hurt or how many claims are filed. If a deck collapses and injures three guests, that is one occurrence, and one limit covers all three claims. Under the standard homeowners forms, repeated exposure to the same harmful condition also counts as one occurrence.
An aggregate limit caps total payments for claims covered by a policy year. The standard commercial general liability (CGL) form has a general aggregate. Under this occurrence form, the policy year depends on when the injury, damage, or covered offense occurs, not when a settlement is paid. The liability section of a homeowners-type policy states a per-occurrence limit only.
A common CGL declarations page shows:
| Limit | Amount | What it caps |
|---|---|---|
| Each occurrence | $1,000,000 | Bodily injury, property damage, and medical payments from one event |
| General aggregate | $2,000,000 | Covered damages and medical payments tied to that policy year, except products and completed operations claims |
| Personal and advertising injury | $1,000,000 | Claims such as wrongful eviction or libel, per person or organization |
| Medical expense | $5,000 | No-fault medical bills for any one injured person |
Medical payments coverage is a small, separate amount the insurer pays for an injured guest's medical bills without anyone proving fault. The Alaska Division of Insurance notes that most homeowners policies include at least $1,000 of it. It does not pay tenants for injuries in their own units under the CGL form.
Example with an aggregate. Your CGL policy has a $1 million per-occurrence limit and a $2 million general aggregate. A stair fall, balcony collapse, and dog bite in a common area all cause covered injuries during that same policy year. The insurer pays $900,000 for the stair fall and $1 million for the balcony collapse, using $1.9 million of that year's aggregate and leaving $100,000. If the dog bite claim then settles for $300,000, the policy pays $100,000 and you owe $200,000. These payments reduce that policy year's aggregate even if made in later years; renewal does not replenish coverage for these earlier injuries.
Do legal defense costs reduce the limit?
Under the standard forms, no. The homeowners forms list claim expenses, including the costs of a suit the insurer defends, as coverage "in addition to the limits of liability." The CGL form says its supplementary payments, which include all expenses the insurer incurs in defending you, "will not reduce the limits of insurance."
Two conditions limit this:
- Defense ends when the limit is paid. Both forms say the insurer's duty to defend ends when it has used up the applicable limit paying judgments or settlements. If the insurer pays its full $500,000 limit to settle one plaintiff's claim, it can stop defending you against what remains of that occurrence, and you pay your own lawyer from there.
- Some policies are written differently. A policy that counts defense costs against the limit, often called "defense within limits," leaves less for the settlement. With a $500,000 limit and $150,000 in legal fees, only $350,000 is left for the injured person. Read the supplementary payments or claim expenses section, and ask your agent in writing if the wording is unclear.
How much liability coverage should a landlord carry?
No single amount fits every landlord, but the starting point is what you could lose. The Alaska Division of Insurance advises weighing the value of your total assets and how much you might lose if someone sued you and won. For a landlord, that includes equity in every rental, your home, and savings outside retirement accounts.
Use these points to set the number:
- Base policy. The Alaska guide says most homeowners policies include at least $100,000 of liability coverage and that landlord policies often offer higher limits because tenants add claims. CGL policies are commonly written at $1 million per occurrence. Many dwelling policies leave liability out unless you add it, according to the North Carolina Department of Insurance, so confirm your landlord policy has a liability section at all.
- Umbrella policy. A personal umbrella pays after your home, auto, or landlord liability coverage stops paying. The Texas Department of Insurance says umbrella coverage usually starts around $300,000 and pays up to at least $1 million. Ask the umbrella insurer what limits it requires on your underlying policies before you buy, and confirm in writing that each rental is listed.
- Ownership. If an LLC owns your rentals, the policy must name the LLC. Ask whether a personal umbrella covers LLC-owned property or whether you need a commercial umbrella. See whether to create a separate legal entity for how an LLC changes your exposure.
Example. You own two rentals with $400,000 of combined equity and have $150,000 in savings. If a covered judgment is $1 million and the insurer pays its $300,000 landlord liability limit, $700,000 remains unpaid. That could expose all $550,000 of those assets, subject to exemptions that protect certain property from collection. A $1 million umbrella on top brings your total to $1.3 million per occurrence.
Requiring tenants to carry their own coverage also keeps some claims off your policy; see why you should require renters insurance.
What a well-designed landlord liability policy includes
A policy that protects a landlord has these features:
- A liability section on the rental itself. A homeowners policy is written for an owner-occupied primary residence, and a basic dwelling policy may cover only the building.
- A per-occurrence limit sized to your assets, with an umbrella when your assets exceed it.
- Coverage for the people who act for you. The CGL form covers your employees for acts within the scope of their work and treats any person or organization acting as your real estate manager as an insured. Confirm that your property manager is covered or carries its own policy.
- Personal injury coverage for wrongful eviction, wrongful entry, and invasion of privacy claims, which bodily injury coverage alone does not reach. Commercial general liability coverage includes these offenses.
The claims a landlord is most often liable for are covered in the tenant injuries you can be liable for.
What falls outside any limit
Some losses are not covered no matter how high your limit is.
Intentional harm. Both the homeowners and CGL forms exclude bodily injury or property damage you expected or intended. The CGL form also excludes personal injury you caused knowing it would violate someone's rights, such as a deliberate lockout.
Punitive damages. These are damages a court adds to punish a defendant and deter similar conduct, on top of compensation for the injury. Courts award them for conduct worse than ordinary carelessness, such as ignoring a known danger to tenants. Whether insurance can pay them depends on your state:
| State | Rule |
|---|---|
| California | Barred. The California Supreme Court held in PPG Industries v. Transamerica (1999) that public policy prohibits insurers from paying punitive damages, relying on Insurance Code section 533, which bars coverage for an insured's willful acts. |
| New York | Barred. The New York Court of Appeals has held that state policy prohibits insurance for awards that are purely punitive, because their only purpose is to punish and deter. |
| Other states | Rules vary by state, and some policies exclude punitive damages in their own wording. Read your policy's exclusions and ask your agent how your state treats them. |
Amounts above your limit. The portion of a judgment left unpaid after insurance is yours to pay, and the plaintiff can seek to collect it from assets not protected by exemptions. In the California case, the insured business could not shift a $1 million punitive award to its insurer, even though it claimed the insurer had refused in bad faith to settle.
For how liability fits with property and loss-of-rent coverage, see the guide to landlord insurance for rental properties.
Sources
- Commercial General Liability Coverage Form CG 00 01 04 13 (Insurance Services Office (copy hosted by Cooper and Scully, P.C.))
- Can I protect my property or income? (Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles)
- The CG 00 01 Form Decoded (Argo Group)
- Homeowners Policy Contents Broad Form HO 00 04 10 00 (filed specimen) (Oklahoma Insurance Department)
- Consumer Guide to Homeowners Insurance (Alaska Division of Insurance)
- Dwelling Policies (North Carolina Department of Insurance)
- Umbrella policies (Texas Department of Insurance)
- PPG Industries, Inc. v. Transamerica Insurance Co., 20 Cal.4th 310 (1999) (Supreme Court of California Resources, Stanford Law School)
- Zurich Insurance Co. v. Shearson Lehman Hutton, Inc., 84 N.Y.2d 309 (1994) (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
Legal Disclaimer: Tellus provides this content for informational purposes only. This is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and locality, and regulations may have changed since this article was published. Consult a qualified attorney for guidance specific to your situation.
Rules in your state
State law sets many of the limits and deadlines described above. These pages cite the statute for each state.
More in Rent It Out
Related reading
Free rental property management tools. Manage rentals from your phone.
There are no fees for opening or using Tellus. Available on iOS and Android.