Rent It Out

Why Should You Require Renter's Insurance?

Require renters insurance because your policy does not cover tenant belongings or a tenant's liability. Put it in the lease, set a $100,000 minimum, and verify proof.

On this page
  1. Can you make renters insurance a lease requirement?
  2. What the tenant's policy covers that yours does not
  3. What minimum liability limit should you require?
  4. How to verify and enforce coverage

Require renters insurance because your landlord policy covers the building, not your tenant's belongings or your tenant's liability for injuries and damage. Without it, a tenant whose belongings burn has no coverage to replace them, and a guest hurt in the unit has no tenant policy to collect from. Where state law allows it, make coverage a written lease term, set a minimum liability limit such as $100,000, and get proof before move-in with your name on the policy as an interested party. Some states limit the requirement: Oregon caps the liability amount you can require and bars the requirement for low-income households and publicly subsidized units.

Can you make renters insurance a lease requirement?

Yes, unless your state or housing program limits it. Put the requirement in the written lease or rental agreement and apply it to every tenant. Where state law says nothing about renters insurance, the requirement is a lease term like any other and binds the tenant who signs. Some states regulate it directly:

State What the law says
Oregon (ORS 90.222) You may require renter's liability insurance only in a written rental agreement, and only if you carry comparable liability insurance yourself and describe that obligation in the agreement. Before a new tenancy, you must tell the applicant in writing about the requirement, the amount, and the exemptions. Coverage required is capped at $100,000 per occurrence or the customary amount for similar local rentals, whichever is greater. You may not require it if household income is at or below 50 percent of area median income, or if the unit is subsidized with public funds such as HOME, CDBG, tax credit, or project-based federal rent subsidies. A Housing Choice Voucher alone does not trigger the exemption.
Virginia (Va. Code section 55.1-1206) You may make renter's insurance a condition of tenancy in the rental agreement and charge the premium for a policy you obtain as rent. You must notify the tenant in writing of the right to obtain a separate policy. A policy you obtain must cover the tenant as an insured, and you must provide an insurer-prepared policy summary or certificate of coverage before lease signing. If premiums are due before move-in, the total of security deposits and insurance premiums cannot exceed two months' rent.

Oregon also bars requiring a particular insurer, requiring you to be named as an additional insured, or requiring the tenant to waive subrogation, meaning giving up the insurer's right to recover claim payments from the party responsible for the loss. A landlord who knowingly violates the section owes the tenant actual damages or $250, whichever is greater.

Existing tenants. You cannot add the requirement to a fixed-term lease before it ends unless the tenant agrees. For month-to-month tenancies, Oregon requires at least 30 days' written notice, including a summary of the exemptions. Other states follow their general rules for changing month-to-month terms.

Assisted housing. If the unit is in a government-subsidized program, check the program's lease rules and regulatory agreement before adding the requirement, and use the same requirement for every tenant.

What the tenant's policy covers that yours does not

The Alaska Division of Insurance explains that a landlord's insurance covers the building and the landlord's own property in the unit, and does not cover the tenant's personal property. The standard renters form, ISO HO 00 04, fills these gaps:

Loss Your landlord policy Tenant's renters policy
Tenant's furniture, clothes, and electronics destroyed in a fire Not covered Covered (personal property coverage)
Tenant's hotel and extra meal costs after a covered loss makes the unit unfit to live in Not covered Additional living expense coverage pays necessary increases over normal living expenses, up to the coverage limit and only for the shortest time needed to repair or replace the damage or settle elsewhere permanently
Tenant's dog bites a guest inside the unit You may be named in the suit; your liability coverage defends covered claims against you Personal liability coverage can pay damages the tenant is legally liable for, up to policy limits, and defend covered claims. Some policies exclude particular dogs or breeds; a higher limit does not remove an exclusion
Tenant's unattended cooking fire damages the building Your property coverage pays, minus your deductible Tenant's liability coverage can pay for the damage the tenant caused
Tenant's overflowing bathtub ruins the bathroom floor in the tenant's unit Your property coverage pays if it covers water damage, minus your deductible Personal liability excludes this; separate coverage may apply, see below

The renters form's personal liability coverage (Coverage E) excludes damage to property the tenant rents or occupies, except damage caused by fire, smoke, or explosion. Water damage, broken fixtures, and pet damage to your unit are not paid under that coverage. However, the cited form's separate Damage to Property of Others coverage may pay up to $1,000 per occurrence for qualifying accidental damage to your unit. Check that coverage before seeking any unpaid amount from the security deposit or the tenant directly, as explained in how to handle tenant damage to your property.

Damage the tenant causes to another unit or a neighbor's belongings is different. The exclusion applies only to property rented to or in the care of the tenant, so the tenant's liability coverage can pay those claims when the tenant is legally liable, such as water from that bathtub ruining the ceiling and furniture in the unit below.

What minimum liability limit should you require?

Require at least $100,000 of personal liability per occurrence. The Alaska Division of Insurance notes that most homeowners-type policies include at least $100,000, so the requirement does not force tenants into special coverage. It is also the most Oregon lets you require, unless a higher amount is customary for similar rentals in your area.

Your own liability coverage still matters, because an injured guest can sue you as well as the tenant. See how liability limits work.

You can also require personal property coverage, but there is less reason to: a tenant who skips it mainly risks the tenant's own belongings.

How to verify and enforce coverage

  1. Write the clause. State the coverage required, the minimum liability limit, the deadline for proof, that coverage must stay in force for the whole tenancy, and that you must be listed as an interested party. Say that failing to keep coverage is a lease violation. The standard terms in a lease shows where it fits.
  2. Get proof before handing over keys. Ask for the declarations page, which shows the tenant's name, your property address, the liability limit, and the policy dates.
  3. Be named as an interested party. An interested party gets notice from the insurer if the policy is canceled, not renewed, or reduced. It gives you no right to collect under the policy. An additional insured is different: it would extend the tenant's liability coverage to you, and Oregon bars landlords from requiring it.
  4. Check at renewal. Put the policy end date on your calendar and ask for the new declarations page each year, or sooner if you get a cancellation notice.
  5. Act on a lapse. Send written notice giving the tenant a short deadline to restore coverage. In Virginia, under the notice and coverage rules above, you may buy coverage for the tenant and charge the premium as rent until the tenant shows proof of a new policy. In Oregon, when you add the requirement to a month-to-month tenancy and the tenant does not get coverage within the 30-day notice period, you may give a for-cause termination notice, and the tenant can cure by getting insurance. Ending the tenancy elsewhere follows your state's notice and court process for lease violations.

Tellus tip

Ask tenants to send the declarations page through the same channel every year, such as your rental portal, and store it with the lease so you can show proof of the requirement if a claim arises.

Oregon also restricts how you use the tenant's policy. You may file a claim against it only when the tenant is legally liable, the amount exceeds the security deposit, and you give the tenant a copy when you file, and never for normal wear and tear.

For how renters insurance fits with your own landlord policy, see the guide to landlord insurance for rental properties.

Sources

  1. ORS 90.222, Renter's liability insurance (Oregon State Legislature)
  2. Va. Code section 55.1-1206, Damage insurance and renter's insurance (Virginia General Assembly)
  3. Homeowners Policy Contents Broad Form HO 00 04 10 00 (filed specimen) (Oklahoma Insurance Department)
  4. Consumer Guide to Homeowners Insurance (Alaska Division of Insurance)
  5. Does renters insurance cover pets? (Progressive)

Legal Disclaimer: Tellus provides this content for informational purposes only. This is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and locality, and regulations may have changed since this article was published. Consult a qualified attorney for guidance specific to your situation.

Rules in your state

State law sets many of the limits and deadlines described above. These pages cite the statute for each state.

StateGuides
CaliforniaCalifornia Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, California Rent Increase Rules for Landlords, California Lease Agreements for Landlords, California Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
New YorkNew York Lease Agreements for Landlords
TexasTexas Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, Texas Landlord Maintenance and Repair Obligations, Texas Lease Agreements for Landlords, Texas Eviction Process for Landlords, Texas Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
FloridaFlorida Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, Florida Landlord Maintenance and Repair Obligations, Florida Lease Agreements for Landlords
New JerseyNew Jersey Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
IllinoisIllinois Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, Illinois Landlord Entry Rules, Including Chicago and Cook County
MassachusettsMassachusetts Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, Massachusetts Landlord Maintenance and Repair Obligations, Massachusetts Lease Agreements for Landlords, Massachusetts Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
PennsylvaniaPennsylvania Lease Agreements for Landlords, Pennsylvania Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
WashingtonWashington Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, Washington Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy
MarylandMaryland Security Deposit Laws for Landlords, Maryland Landlord Entry Rules and Tenant Privacy

More in Rent It Out

Free rental property management tools. Manage rentals from your phone.

There are no fees for opening or using Tellus. Available on iOS and Android.

Get the app